100 Best novels of the 20th century
“Best of” lists are strange and silly things, particularly in the realm of books: as prize shortlists prove time and time again, fiction is a most subjective art. But still, what fun they can be, and how unwittingly revealing. Of Robert McCrum’s 100 Greatest Novels, just 21 are by women. Even allowing for the fact that his list takes in the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries, when women writers were relatively rare, this seems extraordinary to me. Sixty-seven of his titles belong to the 20th century – his final book is Peter Carey’s True History of the Kelly Gang, which was published in 2000 – and yet, only 15 of these are by women. How can this be? The last century offers up an embarrassment of riches when it comes to the female imagination. Is it that Robert thinks men write better, more important novels than women? Or is it simply that he is less familiar with the female canon? I’m not sure. Either way, here I am, eager to help. Let the reprogramming begin.
To take it from the top, I can’t disagree: Jane Austen’s Emma and Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein are masterpieces; so is Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë, Wuthering Heights by her sister, Emily, and Middlemarch by George Eliot. But to this quintet I might add Elizabeth Gaskell’s Mary Barton (1848), whose cast of working-class characters was then such an innovation (Dickens was an admirer). Robert has included Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. It’s a wonderful book, but his neighbour Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin (1852) perhaps deserves to join it. A faulty novel, with a preposterous end, its anti-slavery message nevertheless stirred up great public feeling; its power should not be discounted.
Related: The 100 best novels written in English – quiz
We now reach the 20th century. What strikes me first is how many American writers Robert has chosen (28 of 67), and yet while Edith Wharton, Harper Lee and even Anne Tyler are among their number, he has no space for Eudora Welty, Carson McCullers or Willa Cather. The panting Henry Miller over McCullers or Cather? I don’t think so. So far as British authors go, he gives us no Ivy Compton-Burnett, no Olivia Manning or Antonia White. Surely these writers are more deserving of special attention than, say, stodgy old HG Wells? The two trilogies that constitute Manning’s Fortunes of War series would certainly be on my list, as would White’s autobiographical novel of convent school life, Frost in May (1933). It also seems odd to include Sylvia Townsend Warner’s witchy feminist tale Lolly Willowes (1926) – a good book, but not a great one – and yet to exclude, say, Margaret Kennedy’s The Constant Nymph, the bestseller of 1924, and an exquisite study of jealousy. Naturally, I approve to the very toes of my blue stockings of the fact that Virginia Woolf’s Mrs Dalloway makes his list. But I think a case might also be made for Mollie Panter-Downes’s One Fine Day (1947), in which, over the course of 24 hours, a woman comes to terms with the changes the second world war has brought to her world. It’s a less formally experimental novel than Mrs Dalloway, but the writing, crystalline and true, is just as fine.
Related: On the trail of John Buchan's Thirty-Nine Steps – books podcast
Robert has John Buchan’s The Thirty-Nine Steps on his list, a novel I can imagine very few women holding in such high regard. Patricia Highsmith’s The Talented Mr Ripley (1955) is better written and far more thrilling, if we are to include a page turner, and has been more influential to boot. Similarly, I favour Nancy Mitford’s The Pursuit of Love (1945) or even EM Delafield’s The Diary of a Provincial Lady (1932) over PG Wodehouse’s Joy in the Morning. Both, to me, are just as funny. A children’s novel? He goes for Kenneth Grahame’s The Wind in the Willows. I love it, too, and wouldn’t want to dislodge Ratty, Toad and the others from their perch. But perhaps it could keep company with The Secret Garden (1911) by Frances Hodgson Burnett, in which the healing power of nature saves a family from self-destruction. Mary Lennox, spoilt and troubled, was the first heroine who really spoke to me.
In the second half of the century, I second Robert’s inclusion of Doris Lessing’s The Golden Notebook and Marilynne Robinson’s Housekeeping; ditto The Heat of the Day by Elizabeth Bowen – one of the very finest evocations of wartime London – and Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont by Elizabeth Taylor, a brilliant novelist whose work is still too little known (though I might have favoured Angel or A Game of Hide and Seek).
But Erica Jong’s sexual adventure Fear of Flying (1973) strikes me as a glaring omission. As does Margaret Atwood’s (horribly prescient) dystopian fable of 1985, The Handmaid’s Tale, for which Huxley’s Brave New World or Anthony Burgess’s A Clockwork Orange could easily make way (a bit much to have those and Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four).
Others notable by their absence include Pat Barker, Angela Carter and Carol Shields. Carter’s influence cannot be overstated: her allegorical, taboo-breaking narratives have been genuinely influential. Barker and Shields, meanwhile, have given us triumphantly good books in the form of the Regeneration trilogy and the Pulitzer prize-winning The Stone Diaries respectively.
What else? Two other names occur to me – only they belong to men. In the end, I read as a human being, not as a woman, which is why close to half of the books on Robert’s list would also be on mine. Next to Alan Hollinghurst’s 1994 sensationally good The Folding Star, a story of obsessional and rejected love and of the cruelty of beauty, most late 20th-century novels seem flimsy indeed, mere deckchairs to his polished Chesterfield. And then there is JG Farrell, whose 1970 novel Troubles is, to me, perfection between soft covers: funny, tender and wise. Set in a crumbling hotel in Ireland just after the first world war, it is, as I’m always telling people, Fawlty Towers as written by Evelyn Waugh.magic your way magic years daycare magic x calculator magic with a kick magic user's club magic underwear mormon magic to do sheet music magic to do magic the gathering contramágica magic springs magic springs magic shows near me magic roster magic roster magic pro solar string lights magic outside the box magic out to lunch magic like meter magic johnson magic island magic in the air magic game magic cards near me magic bum last location magic between us quotes magic behind words magic at your door magic as opposed to magic magic as a verb imagicorps everything is magic until it becomes routine cmagic5 bmagic1337 vmagic target smagical retreat rmagick composite magic xxl magic xp osrs magic wand made of hollywood magic vs nets magic valley cinema magic up materia ff7 remake magic the gathering magic oven magic outside of hogwarts magic out of this world magic on main street magic on main magic near me magic lamp magic hour nyc magic forest magic dance lyrics magic before dawn magic about number jmagick java example bmagical magic near rhymes magic nails countryside magic mtgo magic mountain front of the line pass magic mixies cauldron magic keyboard magic johnson magic in me magic in front of monkeys magic game magic from the vault magic from bmf magic for humans staged magic as a name magic around synonym magic about water magic about book magic jmagick maven jmagick download do you believe in magic magic magic bmagical pajamas what are the 12 types of magic materia ff7 remake magic vs bird magic shop llc magic over zoom magic off hand magic of opposite word magic hat magic dental magic by txt magic between us magic behind the kunai magic before christmas christine feehan magic at the musicals magic archer gmagick vs imagick even magic square algorithm umagic osim rmagic rx8 wing past magic sets outside magic sacrifice magic xanadu magic vs lakers magic vs bucks box score magic valley electric magic space next to church magic seaweed magic puzzle company magic needle magic inside mlp magic inside magic initiate 5e magic initiate 5e magic house magic gif magic depth chart magic city magic butter machine magic bum leggings magic bum 5th location magic behind the voice actors magic behind the scenes magic awakened magic as an adjective magic against steel dragons magic after dark city winery magic about love jmagick java example god magic among us apk majix from cartel crew magic-pak thru the wall unit magic zombie deck magic zendikar rising magic without props magic wand magic vs bucks magic underwear magic through music magic sponge made of magic quadrant gartner magic past games magic nails countryside magic mike xxl magic leap magic keyboard ipad pro magic inside of you quotes magic by olivia newton john magic before midnight magic at mcdonald's magic against dwemer magic against dwemer gmagick fmagicline emagic sounddiver qmagic suction cup magic years magic words thru the zodiac magic without lies magic with dogs magic vs bucks magic used auto parts magic tiles magic through glass magic the gathering since magic pixies magic over disneyland paris magic over disneyland magic leap magic kingdom open until midnight magic in front of dogs magic fingers magic dance lyrics magic as programming magic armor 5e